Are all studies created equal?
Here is a very different kind of study for the BBB community to ponder. Periodically the research community completes a systematic review, sometimes known as a literature review, of a given area of research. These studies help people who use research to inform their practice and policies to compare across studies within that given area.
This particular systematic review is in the area of auditory processing development. In the article you will see that the researchers have designed a way of selecting the studies (this could be by date, findings, design type etc.) and a system for reviewing the findings. In this case they started with over 1000 studies and reduced it to 10 to review in depth.
Overall the research concluded that “music training enhances auditory processing skills; the longer the training lasts, the more these skills are reinforced”. They go onto suggest that “music training is an effective method that can be potentially used in children to develop their oral and written communication, assist them with the acquisition of auditory skills, and help them improve such skills after acquisition.”
This is a good article to show that research studies have incredible variation. This is why instead of there being one study to rule them all, it might be better to look at this as a puzzle, with every study adding to the overall scene or picture the researchers are trying to create. Some studies fit together perfectly, often these are sequential studies conducted by the same or similar team of researchers, they are following an idea over multiple studies. Some studies definitely don’t fit together and may even produce contradictory results. This is the nature of research and the quest to understand any given phenomenon.
To see how difficult it is to compare studies, scroll through to Chart 1 which lists the studies. You will see how different the age range, length of study and type of study are. While this shows a lot of difference it also shows how auditory processing can be improved by a little and a lot of music learning, and that this improvement can have a positive impact on auditory processing, which is directly related to language learning.
Enjoy!
Music has always been a go-to for lifting our spirits, but did you know classical music might take it a step further by actually helping treat depression?
Founder of Bigger Better Brains, Dr Anita Collins, receives hundreds of emails from students around the world asking questions about neuromusical research. So she decided to record a short video about the most asked questions she has received.
Can music play a role in healthy aging? According to new research, the answer might be yes.
Imagine sitting in a concert hall, completely immersed in the music, when something incredible happens—you and the people around you begin to breathe and feel the same rhythm.
We're thrilled to announce the launch of our Trick or Treat Digital Campaign for Halloween. Enter your email and receive the campaign now!
As a music teacher, how often have we heard the phrase, “I have to skip rehearsal, I have a test”? In my school, as in many schools, we have our only rehearsal time in the morning prior to school starting, and I hear this comment regularly through the school year.
A new research project will investigate if singing together could be more than just a pleasant pastime; it might be a powerful tool for enhancing cooperation across various aspects of society, from classrooms to boardrooms.
Introducing our exciting new ‘If You’re Aiming for This…’ campaign, created to help you engage with your community like never before!
Many of us have experienced those catchy tunes that get stuck in our heads, but did you know that nearly 45% of people can sing these earworms in perfect pitch?
Singing in a community choir is more than just a musical activity—it's a powerful therapeutic experience
There is a commonly held belief that learning music should only be for those students who are identified as talented or interested. Neuromusical research has shown that music learning can benefit all students in terms of cognitive development.
We're thrilled to announce the launch of our Olympics 'Wanna Be Like...' campaign, created to celebrate the excitement of the 2024 Olympic Games!
Take our free, 60 second quiz and maximize your advocacy impact by discovering your advocacy style and knowledge gaps.
Imagine a world without music. There are no high school marching bands, no commercial jingles, and no need for Grammy Awards. It’s a rather dreary thought, yes?
Recent research has revealed that brain training programs for children do not lead to significant improvements in real-world cognitive functions.
Imagine a world where music serves as a powerful tool for healthy aging. Dr. Psyche Loui at Northeastern University explores how music strengthens brain connections, enhancing memory and emotions.
Dr. Seinfeld's research involving participants aged 60 to 85 found that those who took piano lessons showed remarkable improvements in executive functions, attention, and inhibitory control.
Neuroscientist Nina Kraus notes that playing an instrument is one of the richest brain activities, leading to better language and reading skills.
I have been privileged to walk the road with many schools as they transform their school through music learning.